Wise Pies Pizza & Subs: What’s Vegetarian Editorial Review

Wise Pies Pizza & Subs is open in Terre Haute, Indiana, and it earns a marked-vegetarian tier because it puts a vegan cheese pizza and a vegetarian Caesar pizza right on the standing menu, instead of leaving vegetarian and vegan customers to negotiate substitutions with the kitchen. That’s rare for an independent pizzeria this size, and reviewers specifically call out the vegan cheese pie as a highlight, not an afterthought.

What’s vegetarian and vegan at Wise Pies Pizza & Subs

The menu lists a vegan cheese pizza as its own item, built on the same hand-tossed, thin New York-style crust the shop is known for around town. Multiple reviewers describe the vegan cheese option as genuinely good pizza, with the cheese melting properly rather than sitting on top like a garnish. There’s also a vegetarian Caesar pizza in regular rotation, giving you two distinct choices rather than one plain cheese pie with the toppings removed. Wise Pies also serves subs, and while that side of the menu leans toward meat, it’s worth asking whether any rolls come without it, since the kitchen already accommodates vegan requests on the pizza side.

How to order

Order the vegan cheese pizza by its name on the menu rather than describing what you want and hoping the kitchen improvises. If full vegan is the goal, ask about the crust and sauce too, since Wise Pies also runs specialty pies like a crab rangoon pizza out of the same kitchen, and you’ll want to confirm nothing crosses over. For the vegetarian Caesar, ask whether the dressing itself is meatless, since traditional Caesar dressing includes anchovies even when the pizza topping has no meat on it.

What to watch out for

This is a full-service pizzeria, not a dedicated vegetarian or vegan kitchen, so ovens, cutting boards, and prep counters are shared with pepperoni, sausage, and other meat toppings. If cross-contact matters to you, say so when you order. Also double-check your address before you go. Wise Pies relocated, and the current shop sits at 9 S 6th St, while an older location on South 3rd Street shows up as closed on some review sites and can cause confusion if you’re pulling an outdated listing.

Is Wise Pies Pizza & Subs worth it?

Yes. A family-owned pizzeria that stocks real vegan cheese and keeps a vegetarian pizza on the standing menu is doing more than most independent shops bother with. It’s not a vegetarian restaurant, but if you’re vegetarian, vegan, or just craving pizza in Terre Haute, this is one of the few spots in town where you order straight off the printed menu instead of asking the kitchen to make an exception. Reviewers rate it well above average for a casual pizzeria, with the crust and sauce balance drawing particular praise.