Crumbl Cookies: What’s Vegetarian Editorial Review

Crumbl Cookies is an easy stop for vegetarians. The everyday classics are built on butter, eggs, and milk, not meat, so most of what’s in the case is fair game. The catch is the rotating weekly flavors, where marshmallow- and gelatin-topped cookies turn up more often than you’d expect.

What to order at Crumbl Cookies

Stick to the six daily classics and you’re on safe ground. Milk Chocolate Chip, Pink Sugar, Snickerdoodle, Brownie Batter, and Chocolate Crumb with Oreo are all made with dairy and eggs but nothing meat-derived, so lacto-ovo vegetarians can order any of them without a second thought. The Milk Chocolate Chip is the flavor most consistently confirmed safe across Crumbl’s own ingredient lists.

What to watch out for

Marshmallow-topped and gummy-candy-topped cookies from the rotating weekly menu aren’t vegetarian, since both typically use animal-derived gelatin. The Celebration Cake gets a caution too, since its sprinkles sometimes carry confectioner’s glaze, which comes from an insect secretion that strict vegetarians may want to avoid. There’s no vegan option here at all, since every classic flavor relies on dairy and eggs. Crumbl posts the ingredient list for every flavor online, so it’s worth a quick check before you order anything from the rotating slots, since a safe classic one week can be replaced by a marshmallow-topped flavor the next.